6

It may happen that I ask a question and the problem shows to be a bug.

Should I just delete it?

Should I flag it to be closed and thus stay visible?

Should I post an answer linking to a bug report and possible solutions?

1
  • 1
    Just leave it. If you want, comment with the bug report but it's better for it to stay there - as a dupe target if nothing else.
    – user3
    Commented Jul 9, 2015 at 15:04

2 Answers 2

9

Updated: If you click on close button and select off-topic you will see first option says "Questions about bugs and feature requests are off-topic because they cannot be resolved via Q&A.......". Please use this one from now on.


It should be closed as a duplicate of this question, but not deleted. There's no real answer that can be given since it's not a real question. So it would just be open forever. StackExchange isn't a place that we can use to track bug reports. I think the idea is that questions should be answerable. We should inform the OP that bugs are tracked in launchpad and link to the relevant tracker.

I've also heard people many times say that they "want to make sure it is a bug". However this process is already handled in Launchpad. Issues in Launchpad start out as "new" (aka unconfirmed) and they must be "confirmed". Part of the bug reporting process is confirming the issue. It is done much more quickly if everyone is reporting information in the same place.

There is also a guide on our website about how to make good bug reports.

Perhaps we should put together a canned response that contains all of this information?

3
  • If there is no existing bug report, you'll need to file a new one :) Commented Jul 9, 2015 at 19:16
  • Well... That was no bug. Removed that.
    – user170
    Commented Jul 9, 2015 at 19:19
  • 1
    I'm not sure how closing as duplicate is appropriate here, but it seems to have been decided... Duplicate is not a replacement for off topic, and shouldn't be used as such.
    – user3
    Commented Jul 14, 2015 at 16:55
4

This site does not aim to be, and should not be, a bug report or feature request site. If a question is clearly a bug report or a feature request, redirect the asker to the bug tracker. The best way to do that would be to:

  1. Post a canonical question explaining how to report a bug, like the one on Ask Ubuntu. Done: How can I report an issue with elementary OS to the developers?
  2. Close all questions that are clearly bug reports with a site-specific close reason stating that bug reports and feature requests are not welcome on this site, and linking to this canonical question which explains where to submit them.

(Note: an earlier version of this answer recommended closing as a duplicate of the canonical question, but this is not good because of a Stack Exchange feature: when anonymous visitors visit an unanswered question that is closed as a duplicate, they are automatically redirected to the duplicate. If someone finds a question titled “Why does my cursor disappear in Editor with an Nvidia graphics card?”, but lands on “How can I report an issue with elementary OS to the developers?”, that would be very confusing.)

If you recognize the bug as one that is already reported, post a link in a comment.

But don't be too aggressive on questions that may lead to a bug report. A lot of askers don't know whether what they're observing is a bug or not (it's hard enough for professionals to figure out sometimes!).

If a question is looking for ways to diagnose a problem, answer, explaining how to diagnose the problem. If the diagnosis turns out to be a bug, that's no reason to close the question: it's about the diagnosis, not about the bug.

If the question asks how to solve a problem, and the problem turns out to be due to a bug, do not close the question. Indicate how to report it as a bug, but leave it open for people to answer how to work around the bug.

2
  • 1
    I've created a question about reporting bugs. That's a great idea: elementaryos.stackexchange.com/questions/387/… Commented Jul 11, 2015 at 15:35
  • That's important - a lot of issues people will have will be bugs, but that doesn't mean there is no solution.
    – user3
    Commented Jul 13, 2015 at 11:18

You must log in to answer this question.